Obsidian Tavern
Obsidian Tavern

Historical Fiction Writing Prompts: Characters Edition

A comprehensive Writing Prompts for Historical Fiction writers working on Characters. Free worldbuilding resource from Obsidian Tavern.

Historical fiction characters must feel authentic to their time period while remaining relatable to modern readers. These prompts will help you develop characters who are shaped by their historical context yet driven by timeless human motivations that transcend centuries.

1

Create a character whose profession is becoming obsolete due to technological or social changes in their era. Show how they adapt, resist, or find unexpected opportunities in this transition.

Consider lamplighters during the advent of electric street lighting (1880s), scribes after Gutenberg's printing press (1450s), or blacksmiths during early industrialization (1800s). Research what new roles these displaced workers actually moved into historically.

Genre twist: Make your character's obsolete skill crucial to solving a central plot problem—perhaps a medieval illuminated manuscript copyist whose intimate knowledge of inks helps expose a forged document that could change a royal succession.
2

Develop a character who holds a social position that contradicts their personal beliefs or identity, forcing them to maintain a careful facade while pursuing their true convictions in secret.

Think beyond obvious examples like closeted individuals or religious converts. Consider a Roman senator's daughter who believes in early Christian charity, a Confederate officer's wife who aids the Underground Railroad, or a Victorian gentleman scientist who secretly believes in women's intellectual equality.

Genre twist: Create a moment where maintaining their facade becomes impossible, forcing them to choose between social survival and personal integrity—and show the realistic consequences of 18th-century social ostracism or Roman political disgrace.
3

Design a character whose daily life is governed by a historical practice, belief, or superstition that modern readers might find strange, but make this element essential to their decision-making and relationships.

Research specific practices: medieval Christians structuring days around canonical hours, Ancient Romans consulting auguries before major decisions, or Edo-period Japanese adhering to strict social hierarchies. Show how these aren't just background details but actively shape plot choices.

Genre twist: Have your character's adherence to this historical practice put them at odds with other characters from their own time period who are more progressive or skeptical, creating internal historical tension rather than just historical-vs-modern conflict.
4

Create a character who serves as a cultural bridge—someone who moves between two different worlds within their historical period and must constantly shift their behavior, language, and loyalties.

Consider interpreters during colonial encounters, merchants traveling the Silk Road between vastly different cultures, servants in great houses who navigate both upstairs and downstairs societies, or mixed-race individuals in stratified historical societies.

Genre twist: Place your bridge character in a situation where their dual loyalties create an impossible choice, and explore how their unique perspective allows them to see solutions that characters firmly rooted in one culture cannot.
5

Develop a character whose expertise or knowledge was considered revolutionary or dangerous in their time period. Show how they navigate sharing their insights while protecting themselves from persecution or ridicule.

Research figures like early anatomists dissecting cadavers illegally, astronomers promoting heliocentric theory, women practicing medicine without formal training, or natural philosophers proposing evolution before Darwin. Understand the specific risks they faced and the coded language they used.

Genre twist: Create a scenario where your character must choose between advancing human knowledge and protecting their community—perhaps a plague-era physician whose understanding of contagion could save lives but would require challenging religious authorities who control medical practice.

How to Use These Prompts

When developing these characters, research the specific material culture of their era—what they ate, wore, and owned—as these details will inform their worldview and daily concerns. Create internal conflicts that arise naturally from their historical circumstances rather than imposing modern psychological frameworks. Remember that historical characters should surprise modern readers not through anachronistic behavior, but through the logical yet unexpected ways people navigated the constraints and opportunities of their specific time and place.

The best historical fiction characters feel inevitable within their historical moment while remaining unpredictable in their individual choices. Use these prompts to create people who could only exist in their specific time and place, yet whose struggles speak to universal human experiences.