Obsidian Tavern
Obsidian Tavern

Fantasy Writing Prompts: Characters Edition

A comprehensive Writing Prompts for Fantasy writers working on Characters. Free worldbuilding resource from Obsidian Tavern.

Fantasy characters thrive when they're deeply rooted in their magical worlds, carrying the weight of ancient histories, forbidden powers, and supernatural bonds that shape their every decision. These prompts focus on the unique psychological and social complexities that arise when your characters must navigate both human nature and otherworldly forces. Each scenario explores how fantasy elements can create internal conflict and drive character development beyond typical coming-of-age or hero's journey arcs.

1

Your character discovers they are the reincarnation of someone who committed an unforgivable act in their past life—and the victims' descendants now serve as their closest allies, unaware of the truth.

Memory, identity, and inherited guilt create powerful internal conflicts. Consider how past-life memories surface gradually, what moral obligations span lifetimes, and whether redemption is possible for crimes committed by a previous incarnation. This works especially well with fantasy cultures that believe in cyclical reincarnation.

Genre twist: The character's current noble actions might be unconsciously driven by past-life guilt, creating a complex moral loop where their heroism stems from ancient shame rather than pure virtue.
2

Your character's magical familiar/bonded creature is slowly dying, and the only way to save it is to transfer the bond to someone the character despises—permanently severing their connection to access that familiar's power.

Explore the depth of supernatural bonds versus personal animosity. The familiar might hold crucial magical abilities, emotional support, or be the character's last link to a lost culture. The despised person could be a rival, former friend, or someone who represents everything the character opposes.

Genre twist: Once the transfer occurs, the character must watch their former familiar thrive with someone else, potentially becoming a more powerful force for opposing ideologies while losing their own magical strength.
3

Your character inherits a sentient magical artifact that contains the trapped soul of an ancestor who strongly disapproves of every choice the character makes, offering constant criticism and outdated advice.

Family legacy meets modern fantasy problems. The ancestor lived in different times with different values, creating generational conflict amplified by magical imprisonment. Consider how the artifact's power might be tied to the ancestor's approval or how breaking free might mean losing family heritage forever.

Genre twist: The ancestor's 'outdated' advice occasionally proves surprisingly relevant to magical threats, forcing the character to distinguish between generational wisdom and genuine obsolete thinking while under pressure.
4

Your character can see the 'death-threads'—supernatural connections showing how each person they meet will die—but recently noticed their own thread has become tangled with someone whose death-thread keeps changing, suggesting an uncertain magical fate.

Prophecy and fate mechanics create unique relationship dynamics. Explore how knowing everyone's death affects social bonds, whether the character tries to prevent deaths or accepts fate, and what it means when magical intervention makes destiny uncertain. The changing thread person becomes simultaneously hopeful and terrifying.

Genre twist: The uncertainty might indicate the other person is protected by powerful magic, is actually immortal, or represents a nexus point where multiple timelines converge, making them either the key to saving everyone or destroying the natural order.
5

Your character is a shapeshifter whose animal form is gradually becoming more dominant, and they're starting to forget human concepts like mercy, complex language, and long-term planning when in human shape.

Identity erosion through magical transformation raises questions about what defines humanity versus animal instinct. Consider how relationships deteriorate as the character becomes more primal, what aspects of civilization seem increasingly meaningless, and whether this change represents corruption or natural evolution.

Genre twist: The animal consciousness might actually be more perceptive about supernatural threats that human rational thinking dismisses, creating scenarios where embracing the transformation saves lives while sacrificing the character's human relationships and moral complexity.

How to Use These Prompts

Focus on how magical elements amplify universal human emotions rather than replacing them—fear, love, guilt, and ambition become more complex when supernatural forces are involved. Use your fantasy world's specific magic system rules to create impossible choices, and remember that the most compelling fantasy characters are those whose magical problems illuminate very human struggles with identity, morality, and connection.

The strongest fantasy characters emerge when their supernatural circumstances force them to confront fundamental questions about identity, morality, and what it means to be human. Let your magical elements serve the character development, not overshadow it.